Pat Murphy's Scandal at ASU

The 2009 season for Arizona State University’s baseball team was another year showcasing the talent of the program. A third year in a row as Pac-10 Conference Champion and an acclaimed roster including two Golden Spikes semifinalists, it seemed head coach Pat Murphy’s leadership would continue to reign for years to come. Murphy had served as ASU’s head baseball coach since 1995, achieving notable success with four College World Series appearances that featured a national championship game appearance in 1998, and a 629–284–1 record.  Murphy had just come off of leading the Sun Devils to a semifinal appearance in Omaha the past season, but in November of 2009, Murphy was forced to resign amid an NCAA investigation into the baseball program’s compliance with regulations.

The NCAA’s investigation, covering the period from 2004 to 2009, uncovered multiple violations. The first violation the Sun Devils faced was Impermissible Recruiting Calls. Over 500 unauthorized phone calls were made to prospective student-athletes, violating the NCAA’s one-call-per-week rule. Another violation they were charged with is the use of impermissible recruiters. A team manager, who was not authorized as a recruiter, was involved in persuading a prospect to commit to ASU.  Scholarship Mismanagement was another offense that the NCAA uncovered during their investigation against ASU.  The “Devil-to-Devil” program encouraged current players to relinquish portions of their scholarships to fund incoming recruits, contravening NCAA rules.  Murphy’s nonprofit organization paid 20 players a total of $5,889.34 for work not performed, giving them improper benefits  Lastly, the investigation found an overall lack of institutional control over the Arizona State baseball program. The NCAA cited ASU for failing to monitor its baseball program adequately, marking its ninth major infraction—the most of any NCAA member at the time. 

As a result of these findings, the NCAA imposed several penalties on ASU’s baseball program. First, a one-year postseason ban for the 2011 season, which would be appealed over the 2011 season and instead upheld and be served during the 2012 season.  Second, a three year probation resulting in reductions in scholarships and recruiting activities that would start at the release of the scandal in 2010. Third, the NCAA vacated the 44 wins from the 2007 season.  Lastly, Murphy received a one-year show-cause penalty, requiring any NCAA member institution hiring him during that period to demonstrate compliance measures. 

Following the 2009 season, Pat Murphy involuntarily resigned as head coach of the Sun Devils.  After Murphy's departure, assistant coach Tim Esmay was appointed interim head coach for the 2010 season, and later secured the position permanently after leading the team to a successful season that would end in Omaha.  Murphy transitioned to professional baseball, eventually serving as the interim manager for the San Diego Padres in 2015 and  later taking over as Milwaukee Brewers’ manager in November 2023.  Although both Murphy and ASU recovered from their consequences, the scandal underscored the importance of compliance and institutional control within collegiate athletics, serving as a cautionary tale for programs nationwide.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Is JUCO Really the Next Best Option Outside of DI?

      Have you ever wondered  why JUCO is the undisputed level right below Division I?  It is no secret that the first dog to the bowl of all major DI kickbacks are the junior colleges (NJCAA), but why?  Are they in desirable cities?  Do they have really nice facilities like small private high schools do? At least offer a higher level education while they play there?  The answers to all of these questions are no, and obvious ones at that.  JUCO's are notorious for being in small towns, having rundown facilities, and lacking amenities in general. On top of that, the only degree that you can get from a junior college is of course an associate degree.  It is to a point where similar to the military, the players learn to 'embrace the suck' often referring to themselves as 'JUCO Bandits.'  Despite all of the hype behind the JUCO route, players who do not receive the DI offer that they were hoping for are left after just two seasons witho...
Read more

The Regrettable Rush to Commit

     5am: Time for another three plus hour trip to some town that I have never heard of, for yet another showcase camp to try and gain the attention of schools that I have never heard of, as they barely even turn their heads at my efforts.  But, hey, that is the life for an uncommitted high school senior in the middle of his fall semester.  At this point, I had already come back from summer break to start my senior year and, as it did for many of my fellow teammates, a crushing sense of reality had start to set in.   Everyone was aware that DI programs are always one year ahead in the recruiting cycle, and my graduating teammates had already been selected for their programs.  Teammates of mine who you would have sworn were going to play in college come hell or high water were now talking about this upcoming season being their last, what college they wanted to go to, and what frat they wanted to join.  It was surprising to see, but if I was being ...
Read more

Augie Garrido: The legacy he left behind

       Augie Garrido is one of the most iconic and successful coaches in the history of college baseball. With a career that spanned over five decades, Garrido left an indelible mark on the sport, transforming programs, mentoring generations of players, and becoming the winningest coach in NCAA Division I baseball history at the time of his retirement.   Born on February 6, 1939, in Vallejo, California, Augie Garrido began his baseball journey as a player. He played college baseball at Fresno State and later spent time in the minor leagues, including a stint in the Cleveland Indians organization. His playing career may not have reached the major leagues, but it laid the foundation for his future as a coach and mentor.     Augie would begin his head coaching career in 1969 at San Francisco State, a small division II school.  He would spend only one season as the head man there before moving on to Cal Poly, who was also a DII program at the tim...
Read more